High school office assistant by day, porn video star by night – should there be ramifications?

Christina Catenacci, BA, LLB, LLM, PhD

Time to read 2 minutes read
Calendar April 1, 2011
Image: theglobeandmail.com

Image: theglobeandmail.com

A Quebec school board has suspended a high school office assistant with pay after discovering she also happened to be a porn video star on the side. How did the school board find out about her extra-curricular activity? A student found out her secret and posted it on Facebook, and almost instantly, she was a high school celebrity.

She is waiting to hear what will happen next, and afraid of losing her job.

What should happen to her?

Should she be terminated because of her off-duty activities? Is it appropriate for the assistant and member of the school commission to be penalized by the school board for something she did in her private life? Could she be disciplined simply because the school board is of the view that it is morally wrong do engage in this kind of business?

The last time I checked, there were 396 comments about the article reporting on this situation. Some view the employee’s out of school activities as her own business and concerning her private life, but others see that a dirty video distributed on the Internet is not private at all and could influence the employee’s ability and credibility when performing her job.

Past cases have confirmed that employee’s off-duty conduct can harm a company’s reputation and justify discipline up to and including termination with cause. The law does recognize that an employee has a privacy interest in his or her off-duty conduct, but this must be weighed against the employer’s reputational interest.

For example, we have seen that courts have recently upheld terminations where the employee engaged in off-duty blogging or posting on Facebook that was harmful to the employer’s reputation. That is, employees who use technology to publicly criticize their employer and co-workers could be on the hook for receiving some discipline.

Does participating in pornographic videos that are distributed on the Internet fall in the same category? Does it decrease the office assistant’s credibility such that she can no longer be taken seriously in a school board environment?

What do you think?

Christina Catenacci
First Reference Human Resources and Compliance Editor

Table of Contents

Compliance Made Easy®

Canada’s most trusted compliance software for quick and easy HR, payroll, and internal controls compliance and policy management.
Book a Demo

Related Posts

Imagen 1

Sleeping on the Job? What do you have to do to get fired in Canada, anyway?

Employees can be dismissed for cause, and therefore without notice or severance, when their misconduct or performance is so egregious that the employment relationship has been irreparably harmed. In assessing this issue, employers must adopt a contextual approach, which considers not only the misconduct in question, but the entirety of the employment relationship.

Rudner Law, Employment / HR Law & Mediation

Read more
Imagen 1

The new age of workplace gossip – TMI!

I’ve discussed workplace gossip here before, and what bosses can do to prevent it or at least reduce the potential harm, but there are a couple of hyper-modern developments that I didn’t get into: reality television and the Internet. These two things have created a culture of “sharing”, for lack of a better word, that encourages people at play or work to divulge the most mundane and private details of their lives to others—the kind of information that one previously might only have shared with family or best friends.

Adam Gorley

Read more
Imagen 1

Privacy risk management – by design

I’ve discussed the Privacy by Design principle before, in the Inside Internal Control newsletter. In case you don’t know, PbD is an approach developed by Dr. Ann Cavoukian, the Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, which proactively embeds privacy protection by default in the design of an organization’s practices and products.

Colin Braithwaite

Read more